• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Conway Pizza

At Conway Pizza, we're passionate about crafting authentic and delicious Italian cuisine. Nestled in Conway, PA, our small, unassuming eatery has earned a loyal following for its fresh, flavorful pizzas and hearty wings. Customers rave about our Sicilian pizza, praised for its rich sauce and satisfying heft. We prioritize quality over everything, even if it means occasionally running out of ingredients—it's all part of our charm. Our casual environment welcomes families and friends alike, complete with takeout and outdoor seating options. At Conway Pizza, every order reflects our commitment to great food and genuine service, inviting you to experience the taste of home.

Conway Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Melvin S.
Melvin S.

I just moved to Conway and have wanted to try this place years of driving past the place. If you are looking for a local business (not a national chain) with great food, you can't go wrong. Had the Sicilian pizza that I hoped would be in the neighborhood of good that a restaurant I grew up on provided and I was not disappointed. Part of the charm for me is that some times they run of things. This is a real small business worthy of your support. Great people and experience.

Matt D.
Matt D.

Still THE BEST and every time I am back in town visiting my parents this is the first stop once I get off the plane. Can't get enough of these wings (seasoned dry rub). Insane good taste, huge size, really reasonable pricing and great people.

Lindsay M.
Lindsay M.

This four star review is for the food not the whole experience. We ordered two pizzas and one dozen wings, and they said 30 minutes. It was ready at that time but the price was a little high. The prices online are wrong...super wrong. Online the prices were two pizzas for $19.50 and wings $12.50. Our total was $52.00! That was a little annoying. The pizza was great and the wings were cooked perfectly!

Spencer S.
Spencer S.

Business are hurting right now trying to find workers to staff their establishments and inflation on food prices. When I called I was interested in getting a Special Pizza and 1/2 dozen wings but the proprietor told me they didn't have all the ingredients for the pizza and they didn't have any chicken wings since their wholesale price was $15 bucks for 1/2 a dozen and no one was going to pay those prices. I certainly wouldn't have. They also don't have pizza by the slice anymore. So instead we ordered a pepperoni pizza and gratefully there were ingredients for this even if the new price is $16.11 when it was under $13 last year. Glad we could order local and pick up 35 minutes later. Pizza was pretty good and I think we'd definitely consider coming back again.

Earline B.
Earline B.

I have driven by this place a thousand times and finally tried it. It's a take-out only place so make sure you call ahead to order your food. I ordered a Sicilian Pizza and 2 Dozen Dry Rub Wings. The pizza was so good! Only one size, large square, sauce was so good! The pizza box was SO heavy! Very filling!!! The Wings...... This is where it's at! It is so hard to find places anymore that serve full size wings and this place has them, and they are so good! They were cooked pretty well but next time I would ask for them to be a little crispier as I like when the skin is crispy all over.

Richie S.
Richie S.

This is by far the best pizza and wings in the valley. I see a lot of reviews on here saying the people are rude but we have ordered here for years and never once had that experience- they're actually pretty cool. I'm going in for 2 minutes tops to grab food and they're always busy, so if they're not too talkative because they're doing ten other things, I could care less. Even if they were rude, the food is so good that I'm willing to get cussed out by them to get it- we make a 20 minute trip to go get it. Forget all the stuck up Yelpers on here that want them to kiss their butts when they pick up their food- Order from this place- It's so worth it.

Dan H.
Dan H.

Really good pizza pies. Real deal Italiano! Try the meatza pizza pie for a real good pie!

Roy R.
Roy R.

Composite. I am a fan of this place. Huge indoor oven. Excellent sandwiches (and prepared to custom order). Quick service. Hoagies is all I ever get there. Price is EXCELLENT, and wrapped in foil to keep warm on the way home. A wonderful place to stop on the way home from work. Pizza and Hoagies. Easy access from the street, adequate parking. For the hoagies, I always ask them to crisp them up a bit. A neighborhood institution for sure. NOTE -- they are a combined PIZZA and HOAGIE place. The name is a bit misleading but then again virtually all pizza places do multiple items. Yes, Yelp in SF... f8 and be there.

Christopher D.
Christopher D.

I'm new to this area and I really have become a fan of this place. Now, with the word pizza on the sign I bet you're thinking to try the pizza. Don't. Ok, maybe try the Sicilian but don't waste your time on the pizza. Sauce is decent but the crust is just a little chewy and pretty bland. BUT if you want something great try their hoagies. I've had the steak and the hot italian NUMEROUS times and they always impress. Decent size, great price (under $7) and tasty as hell. Tired of those? Try the calzone! Thick and full of good stuff I get these when they are on special on tuesdays (buy one get one half price) and with one exception have been awesome. I kept hearing this place had great wings but have a rule about ordering wings from pizza places (its like my rule about dating whackadoodles, but sometimes rules are meant to be broken) and recently tried them. They are FANTASTIC and cheap on weds. Try the mild first because either my affinity for hot food has diminished with age or the hot is way too hot. You can't go wrong with these and you'll miss out if you don't at least try them. Anyway, they are quick, will deliver for $6 min order and overall have been consistent. If there is any knock on them for some reason they close early on the weekends. I called at 9:45 on a friday to order a sub and they were closed. They also close really early on sundays. I don't get that. Close early on a tuesday, not a weekend day. I mentioned to the owner that I wasn't a fan of the pizza because of the crust and his response was "well, that's because they didn't cook it long enough...". Ummm, well, that sounds like a management issue, but he didn't seem too concerned. That's ok, i'll just take the steak sub please.

Location

  • Conway Pizza
    1126 Foote St #1204, Conway, PA 15027 Hotline: (724) 869-8222

Welcome to Conway Pizza, a hidden gem located at 1126 Foote St #1204, Conway, PA. This cozy Italian eatery delivers a slice of authenticity that is hard to find in today’s fast-paced dining landscape. With a range of offerings from classic pizzas to tantalizing wings, Conway Pizza stands out as a local favorite and an unclaimed hotspot for pizza lovers.

What makes Conway Pizza particularly appealing is its dedication to quality ingredients and homemade taste. Their menu features delicious choices, such as:

  • Pizzas - Don't miss the **Sicilian pizza** praised for its rich sauce and hefty portions.
  • Wings - Their **dry rub wings** are a crowd favorite; served large and bursting with flavor.
  • Pastas - Options like **Chicken Parmesan** and **Baked Ziti** offer heartwarming comfort food.
  • Salads - A selection of fresh salads for a lighter option, ideal for sharing.

Customers rave about the size and quality of the food, particularly the wings and pizza. One enthusiastic review highlighted: "Insane good taste, huge size, really reasonable pricing." However, this local eatery acknowledges that recent inflation has impacted prices, which some customers found to be different from online listings. Despite minor hiccups, the overall experience shines through, as local patrons willingly support this small business.

Beyond the food, Conway Pizza offers a variety of utilities that make it convenient for diners:

  • Delivery and Takeout options for those on the go.
  • Outdoor seating for enjoying a meal in pleasant weather.
  • A casual, friendly atmosphere perfect for families and groups.
  • Free Wi-Fi and TV for those who wish to make a longer stay.

Conway Pizza is more than just food; it’s a community gathering spot where each visit feels like home. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or planning a gathering, this establishment is dedicated to serving delectable dishes with a personal touch. So, bring your family, friends, or even your appetite and swing by Conway Pizza—you won't be disappointed!

To place your order or to make reservations, give them a call at (724) 869-8222 and experience for yourself why this local pizzeria deserves your support.